The Argument Against Twitter

Last time I raved about Twitter, the latest hot thing in the Web 2.0 world (okay, it’s been up for quite a while now, but it’s only now that its popularity is taking off). But not everyone is happy with Twitter. And they do have their reasons. One such person is Abe Olandres, erstwhile editor of the Blog Herald, and my problogger compatriot. He cites five reasons why we won’t see him on Twitter.

  1. It’s so like blogging in 1999 all over again.
  2. I’m always invisible (or offline) in all my Instant Messengers. Why would I want to be visible on Twitter?
  3. I don’t like to be watched.
  4. I don’t have enough time.
  5. Imagine Twittering on your phone. It could get really expensive.

I’m aware Abe is usually busy with a lot of business and personal undertakings, and being on Twitter is just like telling everyone you’re open to chat. But I think he misses the point when it comes to the microblogging aspect of Twitter. Sure, it’s like 1999 all over again, with micro updates and super-short entries. But then for me, Twitter isn’t meant to replace my regular blog/s. Twitter is meant to compliment my regular blogs, where I would rather post meatier and more substantial material.

Twitter is not for everyone, especially those who value their privacy much (to the point of being paranoid?). But for me, you don’t necessarily have to answer the question what are you doing right now (in 140 characters or less). Some use Twitter as a CB radio of sorts—to broadcast messages to their network of friends (and the public as well, whomever might be listening in).

If you’re not much for Twitter, what are your reasons?

Revolution Theme for WordPress

Related Articles

3 feisty cowboys

  1. [...] The argument against Twitter [...]

    I Just Ditched FireFox in Favor of Safari and Camino | The J Spot said this on April 24, 2007 5:15 am

  2. [...] A few days ago, I wrote Why I Will Never Use Twitter. And thanks to the linklove of Quiet Strength, I was able to read his thoughts on Twitter, as well as those of The Boy Wonder and The Philippines’ Most Influential Blogger. And I got to see Steve Rubel deftly pull the foot out of his mouth. [...]

    Why is Eloquence Important Online? at Fool for Five said this on May 3, 2007 6:50 pm

  3. Yhanks you807239e02911b9128b122a4b297857c4

    http://musicdownloads.tripod.com/music-downloads.html said this on December 11, 2007 3:32 pm

What do you think?